MPs are claiming that executives of online retailers such as eBay and Amazon are “turning a blind eye” to people who handle undervalued or misclassified goods. Many sellers have become well-known on these websites for selling products into the UK without paying VAT. This has led to British businesses getting undercut.
The criticisms came from a meeting of the Public Accounts Committee and parliament’s spending watchdog which is investigating VAT fraud.
The National Audit Office in April said that online retailers outside of the EU had cost HMRC up to £1.5bn because they’re failing to declare tax.
Caroline Flint, a labour member of the committee has challenged eBay and Amazon over their failure to stop fraudsters. She went on to say that both companies were actively encouraging overseas sellers to sell through their platforms and were charging them to do so.
She posed this question to the eBay vice-president: “Whatever your relationship to the seller, the by-product of Amazon and eBay and other online marketplaces is that you are profiting from the evading of tax by these overseas sellers. That is a fact, isn’t it?”
“We don’t want any of these sellers on our platform. If we are notified, we take action,” was Billante’s reply
The impact on UK firms
Committee chair, Meg Hiller said that many companies were having to lay off staff because VAT fraudsters can undercut their prices by 20% as they’re not adding VAT to their prices.
Online sales accounted for 14.5% of all UK sales in 2016. This makes the UK the biggest online market in Europe. Over half of all online sales were through online marketplaces like Amazon and eBay.
Sometimes “overseas” sellers have stock already held in the UK before being sent to the customer. Tax rules state that all traders outside the EU who sell goods to customers in the UK should charge VAT if their goods are already in the UK at the point of sale.
However, both Amazon and eBay say that it’s up to the seller to determine and declare any VAT that arises.
HMRC has come under fire from MPs for not enforcing their rules enough. Jon Thompson, a permanent secretary of HMRC has suggested that making changes to VAT which would see Amazon and eBay liable for paying some of the VAT owed would help fight the problem.
Richard Allen from the group Retailers against VAT Abuse Schemes said that this was affecting other UK retailers. “Twenty per cent is a large sum of money, and if your competitors are avoiding the 20% you can’t compete.”
Amazon has also been among the top companies under fire for not paying its fair share of corporation tax.
What do you think of the potential VAT loss? Do you think Amazon and eBay should share some of the tax burden? Let us know what you think.